Newton, New Jersey – A new locally owned cookie and coffee shop is drawing attention — and sweet aromas — along Main Street in Newton, as a husband-and-wife duo turns a late-night idea into a growing community favorite. Davis Cookie, a drive-thru and walk-up café, officially opened its doors in May 2025, offering fresh-baked cookies, specialty coffee, and a welcoming neighborhood atmosphere.
Incident Overview
Davis Cookie was founded by Anthony Davis and Lindsey Davis, a couple from Green Township, after a simple conversation sparked a business idea. Lindsey’s homemade cookies had long been popular among friends and family, and the couple decided to take the next step by transforming that passion into a full-scale shop.
What began as a casual discussion quickly turned into a serious venture, with the Davises committing time, resources, and careful planning to ensure the business would stand out in Newton’s downtown area.
Timeline of Events
The journey from idea to opening unfolded over several months. The couple began the rental process for a former drive-thru farm stand in a Newton plaza in November 2024. They officially received the keys in January 2025, after which renovations began. By May 2025, Davis Cookie was ready to welcome customers.
The location had been vacant for some time, but with the help of friends and a professional painter who redesigned the exterior, the space was transformed into a vibrant and inviting café.
Details from the Owners
Lindsey Davis recalled the moment the idea became real, saying she believed her cookies were good enough to sell — a statement her husband immediately supported.
“I could sell these,” Lindsey said, recalling the conversation. “And Anthony’s response was, ‘And I would buy them.’”
Anthony Davis quickly took charge of sourcing equipment and securing a location, emphasizing that the business was approached with the same seriousness as any major professional venture.
“We take everything about the business very seriously,” Anthony said. “We even flew in a coffee specialist from Italy to teach us the proper technique and temperatures to make the best Italian coffee.”
Key Facts About Davis Cookie
- Owners: Anthony Davis and Lindsey Davis
- Location: 187 Main St., Newton, NJ
- Opened: May 2025
- Business Type: Drive-thru and walk-up cookie and coffee shop
- Hours:
- Monday–Saturday: 10 a.m. – 8 p.m.
- Sunday: 10 a.m. – 6 p.m.
Community Partnerships and Support
Davis Cookie has quickly become involved in the local community. During the 2025 season, the shop partnered with the Sussex County Miners, offering cookie giveaways during home games.
“It was very interesting when I saw the business with the cookies painted on the building,” said Joann Ciancitto, manager of corporate partnerships for the Miners. “I thought it would be great to get together and see how the Miners could help them promote their brand.”
The promotion has become a fan favorite, especially among children attending games.
“The kids go nuts,” Ciancitto said. “One lucky child gets the cookie, and it’s something they’ve come to anticipate every game.”
Local Leadership Reaction
Newton officials have also shown support for the business. Sandra Diglio, deputy mayor of Newton, praised both the quality of the products and the owners’ dedication.
“I think their products are excellent, and everyone is so nice,” Diglio said. “Another thing that stands out about Davis Cookie is their dedication to both their business and the community. They have fantastic work ethic.”
Family and Future Plans
The business has become a family affair. The couple’s son, Anthony Davis Jr., 7, is a student at the Green School, where classmates have affectionately nicknamed him “The Cookie Man.”
Davis Cookie offers rotating seasonal items, including heart-shaped cookies for Valentine’s Day, and hosts events such as movie nights and ballet performances. Looking ahead, the shop plans to introduce protein cookies and new specialty lattes in the coming months.
Before launching Davis Cookie, the Davises owned an exotic pet business. Lindsey previously worked for Louis Vuitton, while Anthony currently serves as the East Coast regional manager for Safe Haven ADT — experience they say helped prepare them for entrepreneurship.
“We’re passionate about this business and put our hearts and souls into it and the Newton community,” Lindsey said.
Conclusion
With its drive-thru convenience, handcrafted menu, and strong community ties, Davis Cookie is quickly establishing itself as more than just a dessert stop. The shop represents a blend of family values, professional dedication, and local pride — ingredients that appear to be resonating strongly with Newton residents.
Share your experiences in the comments below.
